A fair deal on power for New Zealanders?

Friday, June 21, 2019
A fair deal on power for new zealanders

The government’s Electricity Price Review has recently been completed and is due to be released to the NZ public. The review looked at how to make electricity prices fairer and affordable, as well as and more efficient and competitive.  As we head into winter, we’ve seen lots of attention in the media to how energy hardship is hitting the New Zealanders.

More than 100,000 NZ household experience energy hardship

The Government’s Review reported than more than 100,000 households experience energy hardship by spending more than 10% of their income on power.

Paying a large portion of your income on power, can put homes into power poverty where people have to borrow money to pay their bill, go without, or resort to practical measures like cooking dinner late so they can simultaneously heat the house.

How can we level the field for a fairer Power marketplace?

Consumer NZ research recently found that a third of households on prepay power plans like Globug have had to borrow from family and friends to pay their bills. Although prepaying for power can help homes manage their finances, research found that prepay customers usually end up paying more than they would on the open market, although its discount for Community Services Cardholders helped.

Consumer NZ head of research Jessica Wilson said, "Despite paying for power in advance and receiving a more restrictive service, customers on prepay are charged comparatively high rates and encounter other fees.”

Wilson says, “We've been calling for better consumer protections to ensure prepay customers are treated fairly and don't face disproportionate costs."

So, does moving to a ‘regular’ power plan where you pay a monthly bill make things fairer? Not quite. If you struggle to pay your bill on time and don’t always receive a prompt payment discount then homes facing power poverty still end up paying more than most Kiwis for their power.

TVNZ on prompt payment discounts


The good news is that some NZ Power Providers are following initial recommendations and dropping prompt payment discounts.

Prompt payment discounts recently came to public attention with the release of the first phase of the Electricity Pricing Review by Energy and Resources Minister Megan Woods.

The report indicated that vulnerable households were disproportionately penalised by traditional prompt payment discounts.  “Some households struggle to understand the various plans and how to choose the one that’s best for them, and low-income consumers miss out more often on prompt payment discounts - which can be as high as 26% of the bill, and which budgeting and advocacy groups say are really late-payment penalties.”

Meridian Energy was one of the first providers to announce that they were ditching prompt payment discounts and replacing it with a monthly guaranteed discount of equal value to all customers. 

Earlier this month Contact Energy announced that it was removing prompt payment discounts and simplifying their plans to make them more transparent, fair and accessible.  It’s great to see a major retailer act on the Electricity Pricing Review to make sure New Zealanders get a fair deal on power. And, feedback so far from Power Compare customers has been positive!

Contact Energy Plans


Making an informed choice about power.

At Power Compare we are keen to see how the government’s final report and how NZ can progress toward a fairer more affordable electricity market for everyone. A key finding from the first phase of the government review was that those who don’t actively shop around and compare power plans often pay significantly more. A key way to take control of your power bill today, is to compare plans and make an informed choice.

Want to have your say about the power market in New Zealand? Take the Power Pulse survey to tell us what's important to you when choosing a power plan. Your responses can help other make an informed choice about power, and you could win your power bill paid for three months. 


Power Pulse Survey


Genesis Energy Meridian Energy

Other News

Aug 19, 2019

NZ Compare recognised for excellence in the Westpac Auckland Business Awards

NZ Compare were delighted to be shortlisted as Finalists in an amazing 3 categories for the Westpac Auckland Business Awards 2019. NZ Compare were shortlisted for....

Aug 2, 2019

Are Spot Pricing Power Plans right for you?

Power Companies in New Zealand are offering their customers more innovative ways of buying and managing power for their homes. Is Spot Pricing right for you? Read on to find out more and make an...

Jul 19, 2019

Top ways to cut your power bill this winter

Here are some small changes you can make in your day-to-day life to cut the amount of power you use in your home. Plus, one change that almost every home in New Zealand could make...

Jul 8, 2019

Customer fights for compensation after paying neighbours power bill for years

How closely do you monitor your power bill? A recent report revealed that a man was accidentally paying his neighbours bill by mistake for years. Here’s how settle a dispute with your power company when...

Jul 5, 2019

Are Small Power Providers winning the fight for new customers?

More than 440,000 households switched Power Company last year – and it looks like the big providers have been the biggest losers. So, if you feel like you’re paying too much, or you’re not feeling...